tax, paperwork, accounting, business, finance, budget, economy, taxation, financial, accountant, open book, spectacles, irs, taxpayer, specs, glasses, reference book, law book, learn, study, student, knowledge, swot, read, tax, tax, tax, accounting, accounting, accounting, accounting, accounting, budget, budget, economy, economy, accountant, irs, swot. The seven stages behind every receivable, and the test that catches gaps
Photo by stevepb on Pixabay

Guides

Part of Reading accounts receivable as a beginner bookkeeper: aging, payments and credit notes

The seven stages behind every receivable, and the test that catches gaps

An accounts receivable framework in seven stages, each with its trigger, document, ledger entry and owner, plus the control account test that finds what is missing.

The receivables function fails in one of two ways: money is owed that nobody is chasing, or money is being chased that is not owed. Both come from the same cause, a stage in the cycle with no document and no owner.

The framework below is the cycle, cut into seven stages. For each stage, four questions have to be answerable: what triggers it, what document proves it, what entry it makes, and who owns it. A business that can fill in every cell has a receivables function. A business that cannot has a pile of invoices.

What to take away

  • Seven stages, each with a trigger, a document, an entry and an owner. A blank cell is where money leaks.
  • The customer ledger and the control account in the general ledger must agree to the cent at every month end. That agreement is the framework's only pass or fail test.
  • The chasing stage is the one people focus on, and it is the least important. Most of what makes collections slow was decided at stages one and two.

The seven stages

StageTriggerDocumentEntryOwner
1. Credit decisionNew customer, or a limit reachedCredit application, terms sheetNoneWhoever can say no to a sale
2. InvoiceDelivery of the goods or serviceThe invoice, referencing the orderReceivable up, income upWhoever knows the work is done
3. StatementA fixed day each monthCustomer statementNoneBookkeeper
4. Receipt and allocationMoney arrivesRemittance advice, bank lineBank up, receivable downBookkeeper
5. Query and disputeCustomer objectsDispute log entryNone until resolvedWhoever did the work
6. Chase and escalateAged report, on a scheduleContact logNoneOne named person
7. ResolveDecision on what will not be collectedCredit note, or write-off approvalIncome down, or bad debt cost upOwner or manager, not the bookkeeper

The entries column is short on purpose. Only three stages touch the ledger. The rest are controls, and the framework's value is in making them visible.

Seven stages of receivables

  1. 1 Credit decisionlimit reached
  2. 2 Invoiceon delivery
  3. 3 Statementfixed monthly day
  4. 4 Receiptcash allocated to invoices
  5. 5 Querydispute logged, not chased
  6. 6 Chaseaged report, one owner
  7. 7 Resolvecredit note or write-off

Stage 1: the decision to lend

Every invoice on terms is a loan. That is not a metaphor: a business that grants terms, sets limits and chases balances is doing consumer or trade credit. The federal guidance for businesses on credit and finance is the place to check what obligations come with it in your case.

Does the order wait?

Balance at or over the credit limit?

Yes

next order waits for approval

No

order proceeds on terms

Stage 1 is where the business decides how much it will lend to this customer and for how long. The document is a terms sheet the customer has seen: payment period, what happens on late payment, whether a deposit is required.

Set a limit, however rough. The limit is not a forecast of what the customer will do; it is a trigger for a conversation. When the balance reaches it, the next order waits until someone with authority has looked.

What goes wrong without this stage: the third unpaid invoice is raised to a customer who has never paid the first, because nobody was looking at the balance when the order came in.

Stage 2: the invoice

The trigger is delivery, not the end of the month and not the day someone remembers. The entry is the sale: receivable up, income up, dated when the work was done. That dating rule, and what it does to the period the sale lands in, is the subject of the revenue recording guide.

What a payable invoice carries

  • Customer purchase order reference
  • Correct legal entity named
  • Payment terms stated
  • Bank details included
  • Itemisation matching what they bought

The invoice's job is to be payable on receipt, meaning it carries everything the customer's process needs: their order reference, the correct legal entity, the terms, the bank details, an itemisation that matches what they think they bought. Ask each new customer once what their accounts department needs, and store the answer on the customer record.

What goes wrong: an invoice that is correct in every respect except the missing purchase order number, which then waits a full payment cycle while someone on the other side works out who ordered it.

Stage 3: the statement

A statement is a list of open invoices sent to the customer on a fixed day each month. It makes no entry. Its purpose is to surface disagreements early: the invoice they never received, the payment they think they made, the credit they believe they are owed.

Businesses skip this stage because it seems like admin. It is the cheapest control in the cycle, because it puts the customer's own bookkeeper to work checking your ledger.

Stage 4: receipt and allocation

Money arrives; bank up, receivable down. The discipline is allocation: the receipt is matched to specific invoices, using the remittance advice if there is one and a question to the customer if there is not. Never a lump against the customer.

Allocate, never lump

Allocated receipt

Matching
To specific invoices
Remittance advice
Used if present
Short payment
Noted, sent to 5 or 7
Ledger effect
Invoices close

Lump-sum receipt

Matching
Against customer only
Remittance advice
Ignored
Short payment
Hidden in balance
Ledger effect
Aged report misleads

Short payments and overpayments are noted at this stage and passed to stage 5 or 7. They are not written off here, because the bookkeeper allocating cash is not the person who can decide whether a deduction was justified.

Stage 5: query and dispute

A disputed invoice is not late. It is unresolved, and chasing it as if it were late only annoys the customer.

The dispute log records the customer's objection, the owner of the answer on your side, and the date. The invoice stays open on the ledger, flagged, and leaves the chasing routine until the dispute closes.

The owner of a dispute is whoever did the work, because the question is nearly always about the work.

Stage 6: chase and escalate

One named person, a fixed schedule, and a contact log that records what was said and when. The aged report drives it, sorted by age. The escalation ladder itself, rung by rung, is set out in the accounts receivable overview and is not repeated here.

The framework point is narrower: chasing makes no entry and changes no balance. If a business finds it is spending most of its receivables effort here, the effort is being spent on the symptom.

Stage 7: resolve

At some point somebody decides that part of a balance will not be collected, or should never have been billed. Two different documents, two different entries.

Credit note or write-off

Credit note

Meaning
Sale was wrong
Entry
Income down
Approval
Authorized signer
Bookkeeper
Does not decide

Write-off

Meaning
Sale right, money lost
Entry
Bad debt cost up
Approval
Authorized signer
Bookkeeper
Does not decide

Neither decision belongs to the bookkeeper, and both need written approval from someone authorized to give money away, filed with the entry.

Whether a written-off balance is deductible, and on what basis, is a separate question again. Start from the federal guidance on business expenses and confirm it with your own accountant, rather than assuming the ledger entry settles it.

The one test: control account to customer ledger

Every customer balance, added up, must equal the receivables figure in the general ledger, every month end, exactly. This is the only mechanical test the framework has, and it catches almost everything.

The control account test

  1. Add every customer balance
  2. Compare to receivables control account
  3. Equal exactly at month end?
  4. If not, find the one-sided posting
  5. Fix before closing the month

If the two disagree, something reached one of them without going through the other: a journal posted straight to the control account, a receipt posted to income, or an invoice entered outside the sales process. Find it before closing the month.

How the control account is set up so this test is possible is a chart of accounts question. The monthly routine it belongs to is described in the bookkeeping foundations guide.

Filling in the blanks

Take the table at the top and write your own business into it. The exercise takes half an hour. What it usually shows:

Blanks the exercise usually finds

  • Stage 1 has no owner
  • Stage 3 does not exist
  • Stage 5 has no dispute document
  • Stage 7 done quietly by bookkeeper

Each blank cell is a specific job. Any package worth using can hold the documents in the table; what it needs to do with them is covered in the guide to accounting software.

Common questions

Is this too much structure for a business with twenty customers?
The table takes the same half hour whatever the size. With twenty customers most cells have one name in them, which is fine. The point is that the name exists.
Who should own the chase if there is only the owner and a part-time bookkeeper?
The bookkeeper runs the schedule and makes the calls up to a fixed rung; the owner takes over above it. Write the rung down.
How often should the control account test run?
Every month end, before anything is reported. Weekly if volume is high. It takes minutes when it agrees, and it is the cheapest hour of investigation you will ever spend when it does not.
What about customers who pay by card at the point of sale?
They pass through stages 2 and 4 in one moment and skip the rest. The framework still applies to the processor's settlement, which arrives net of fees and needs decomposing.

More in Guides

Latest from Costs Desk